| Year | Team | Coach | Competition | Division | Grand Final Best Player |
| 2014 | Seniors | Matt Clark | Eastern Football League | Division 3 | Brad Hutchinson |
| 2014 | Reserves | Justin Morgan | Eastern Football League | Division 3 | Hus Yusuf |
| 2010 | Colts | Ian Birkett | Eastern Football League | Division 2 | |
| 2008 | Seniors | Jason Heatley | Eastern Football League | Division 2 | Mark Dimashki |
| 2004 | Seniors | Lee Rowe | Eastern Football League | Division 2 | Michael Migliore |
| 2003 | Reserves | Wayne Sharkie | Eastern Football League | Division 2 | |
| 2002 | Seniors | Stevan Jackson | Eastern Football League | Division 3 | Michael Jamieson |
| 2000 | Colts | Robert Wood | Eastern Football League | Div 3 & 4 Combined | |
| 1996 | Seniors | Laurie Anderson | Eastern Football League | Division 4 | Brendan Ferris |
| 1996 | Reserves | Colin Williams | Eastern Football League | Division 4 | |
| 1995 | Reserves | Colin Williams | EDFL | Division 4 | |
| 1958 | Seniors | Trevor Wightman | MDFL |
Wantirna South Devils