| Year | Senior | Reserves | U19’s/Colts | Veterans |
| 2018 | Jess Sinclair | Sam Bates | Paul Riley | TBA |
| 2017 | Matt Clark | Lukas Slater | Paul Riley | Brad Flower |
| 2016 | Matt Clark | Lukas Slater | Nick Adam | Brad Flower |
| 2015 | Matt Clark | Justin Morgan | Nick Adam | Paul Beddome/Brett Campbell |
| 2014 | Matt Clark | Justin Morgan | Michael Creak | Paul Beddome |
| 2013 | Matt Clark | Justin Morgan | Glenn Edwards | |
| 2012 | Matt Clark | Justin Morgan | Glenn Edwards | |
| 2011 | Matt Clark | Justin Morgan | Glenn Edwards | |
| 2010 | Rod Mitchell | Justin Morgan | Ian Birkett | |
| 2009 | Jason Heatley | Justin Morgan | Ian Birkett | |
| 2008 | Jason Heatley | Justin Morgan | Peter Battle | |
| 2007 | Jason Heatley | Glenn Edwards | Peter Battle | |
| 2006 | Jason Heatley | Paul Payne | Peter Battle | |
| 2005 | Lee Rowe | Paul Payne | Peter Battle | |
| 2004 | Lee Rowe | Wayne Sharkie | Jeremy Neagle | |
| 2003 | Lee Rowe | Wayne Sharkie | Garry Stone | |
| 2002 | Stevan Jackson | Ray Phillips | Garry Stone | |
| 2001 | Stevan Jackson | Ray Phillips | Rob Wood | |
| 2000 | Max Gasparoni | Wayne Nelson | Rob Wood | |
| 1999 | Steven Draper | Garry Moon | Rob Wood | |
| 1998 | Steven Draper | Garry Moon | Brian Berger | |
| 1997 | Laurie Anderson | Garry Moon | Steven Draper | |
| 1996 | Laurie Anderson | Colin Williams | Steven Draper | |
| 1995 | Bruce Beaton | Colin Williams | Steven Draper | |
| 1994 | Bruce Beaton | Ken Withers | No side | |
| 1993 | Ray Trotter | Brian Berger | No side | |
| 1992 | Rod Sutherland | Brian Berger | No side | |
| 1991 | Stephen Trask/Charlie Daniels | Brian Berger | No side | |
| 1990 | Colin Kiker | Ron Griffiths | Tony Ryan | |
| 1989 | Bruce Beaton | Manny De Bono | Tony Ryan | |
| 1988 | Bruce Beaton | Manny De Bono | No side | |
| 1987 | George Bissett | Manny De Bono | Gary Barr | |
| 1986 | George Bissett | Dave Connors | Gary Barr | |
| 1985 | George Bissett | Albert Zantuck | Gary Barr | |
| 1984 | Colin Kiker | Albert Zantuck | Gary Barr | |
| 1983 | Graeme Cinnamond/Wes Ball | Clem Seaton | No side | |
| 1982 | Doug Graham/Bob Taylor | J Reaper | No side | |
| 1981 | Doug Graham | Wes Ball | No side | |
| 1980 | Bill Duff | Wes Ball | No side | |
| 1979 | John Dobson | Les Brick | No side | |
| 1978 | Martin Miles | Les Brick | No side | |
| 1977 | Robin Bailey | Geoff Thompson | No side | |
| 1976 | Robin Bailey | David Atkins | No side | |
| 1975 | Mervyn Day | David Atkins | No side | |
| 1974 | John Newcombe | Des Brown | No side | |
| 1973 | John Newcombe | Ernie Williams | Dave Connors/Barry Ingwersen | |
| 1972 | Colin Williams | Keith Prichett | Stan Day | |
| 1971 | Robert Taylor | Jack Lind | Finn Hansen/Ray Chalker | |
| 1970 | Robert Taylor | Jack Lind | John Slater | |
| 1969 | Robert Taylor | Les Ayers | John Slater | |
| 1968 | Robert Taylor | No side | John Slater | |
| 1967 | Jack Richardson | No side | Alf Baylis | |
| 1966 | Jack Richardson | No side | Alf Baylis | |
| 1965 | Jack Richardson | No side | Bill Skewes | |
| 1964 | Keith Schmidt | No side | Bill Skewes | |
| 1963 | Ian Whitten/Ron Adams | No side | Les Worsley | |
| 1962 | Trevor Collins | No side | Richie Crank | |
| 1961 | Jack Richardson | Bill Thomas | No side | |
| 1960 | Jack Richardson | No side | Jack Richardson | |
| 1959 | Trevor Wightman | No side | Ron Moffatt | |
| 1958 | Trevor Wightman | No side | Bob Dobson | |
| 1957 | Trevor Wightman | No side | Bob Dobson | |
| 1956 | Merv Schultz//Bill Critch | No side | No side | |
| 1955 | Buck Zarro | No side | No side | |
| 1954 | Trevor Wightman | No side | No side | |
| 1953 | Bob Dobson | No side | No side | |
| 1952 | Bob Dobson | No side | No side |
Wantirna South Devils
