| Year | Seniors | Reserves | Colts/Underage |
| 2017 | Tim Lee & | Kyle Brooks & | Dailen Carney & |
| Brent Walker | Jake Stopinski | Nathan Denes | |
| 2016 | Tim Lee & | Kyle Brooks & | Tyson Henry & |
| Brent Walker | Jake Stopinski | Jordan Roberts | |
| 2015 | Andrew Teakel | Kyle Brooks | Travis Clarke |
| 2014 | Andrew Teakel | Kyle Brooks | Aaron Creak & John Rozakis |
| 2013 | Andrew Teakel | Michael Oldenhof | Jimmy Sarinn |
| 2012 | Andrew Teakel | Michael Oldenhof | Josh Stone |
| 2011 | Scott Edgcumbe | Michael Oldenhof | Josh Stone |
| 2010 | Scott Edgcumbe | Michael Oldenhof | Jack Birkett |
| 2009 | Scott Edgcumbe | Ty Huckstepp | Sam McIntyre |
| 2008 | Scott Edgcumbe | Rob Hellier | Koray Barkut |
| 2007 | Michael Jamieson | Justin Morgan | Sam Purdon |
| 2006 | Michael Jamieson | Justin Morgan | Andrew Teakel |
| 2005 | Michael Jamieson | Justin Morgan | Tim Hardham |
| 2004 | Michael Jamieson | Justin Morgan | Andrew Gellatly |
| 2003 | Jason Heffernan | Justin Morgan | Steve Forcucci & Dean Parker |
| 2002 | Jason Heffernan | Justin Morgan | Ty Huckstepp |
| 2001 | Matty Schultz | Shaun Barnett | Jeff Farrell |
| 2000 | Matty Schultz | Paul Constantino | Jason Alexander & David Clyne |
| 1999 | Matty Schultz | Wayne Nelson | Scott Edgcumbe |
| 1998 | Matty Schultz | Bruce Cameron | Sam Barnes |
| 1997 | Matty Schultz | Bruce Cameron | Andrew Mackwell |
| 1996 | Brendan Ferres | Gary Moon | Grant King & Waine Ferguson |
| 1995 | Bruce Beaton | Gary Moon | Scott Myers |
| 1994 | Bruce Beaton | John Hearn | NTF |
| 1993 | Steven Draper | Darren Trotter | NTF |
| 1992 | Rod Sutherland | Garry Jardine | NTF |
| 1991 | Stuart Sonsie | Brian Sweetman | NTF |
| 1990 | Stuart Sonsie | Ron Griffiths | NTF |
| 1989 | Bruce Beaton | Mann De Bono | NTF |
| 1988 | Bruce Beaton | Manny De Bono | NTF |
| 1987 | Chris Rogers | Manny De Bono | NTF |
| 1986 | Mark Edwards | Dave Connors | NTF |
| 1985 | Ron Griffiths | Albert Zantuck | Brendan White |
| 1984 | Ron Griffiths | Albert Zantuck | Steven Draper |
| 1983 | Graeme Cinnamond | Brian Berger | NTF |
| 1982 | Doug Graham | Jim Reaper | NTF |
| 1981 | Doug Graham | Wes Ball | NTF |
| 1980 | Philip Atkins | Wes Ball | NTF |
| 1979 | John Dobson | Les Brick | NTF |
| 1978 | Martin Miles | Jeff Thompson | NTF |
| 1977 | Robin Bailey | Jeff Thompson | NTF |
| 1976 | Robin Bailey | David Atkins | NTF |
| 1975 | Mervyn Day | David Atkins | NTF |
| 1974 | John Newcombe | Des Brown | NTF |
| 1973 | John Newcombe | Ernie Williams | NTF |
| 1972 | Colin Williams | Keith Pritchard | NTF |
| 1971 | Robert Taylor | Jack Lind | W Mickleson |
| 1970 | Robert Taylor | Jack Lind | Colin Voight |
| 1969 | Alex Ingwersen | Richie Crank | NTF |
| 1968 | Alex Ingwersen | NTF | Trevor Vornell |
| 1967 | John Gallagher | NTF | Ray Chalker |
| 1966 | John Leyton | NTF | Bernie Elker |
| 1965 | Jack Richardson | NTF | David Atkins |
| 1964 | Keith Schmidt | NTF | David Atkins |
| 1963 | Ian Whitten | NTF | NTF |
| 1962 | Trevor Collins | NTF | NTF |
| 1961 | Jack Richardson | NTF | Richard Dobson |
| 1960 | Jack Richardson | NTF | Doug Lockwood |
| 1959 | Trevor Wightman | NTF | Doug Lockwood |
| 1958 | Trevor Wightman | NTF | Graeme Finger |
| 1957 | Trevor Wightman | NTF | John Atkins |
| 1956 | Merv Schultz | NTF | NTF |
| 1955 | Buck Zarro | NTF | NTF |
| 1954 | Bob Dobson | NTF | NTF |
| 1953 | Bob Dobson | NTF | NTF |
| 1952 | Bob Dobson | NTF | NTF |
Wantirna South Devils