| 2018 | Will Edwards | Ben Cromb | Sol Mesfin |
| 2017 | Taylor Leggate |
Sam McIntyre Robert Papp(EFL) |
Noah Jackson |
| 2016 | Taylor Leggate | Robert Papp | Ben Gerloff |
| 2015 | Brent Walker & Taylor Leggate | Robert Papp | Jordan Roberts |
| 2014 | Brent Walker | Huse Yusuf**(& EFL) | Stephen Naylor & Tim Phillips |
| 2013 | Brad Hutchinson | Brett Hardham ** | Sean Young |
| 2012 | Chris Phillips | Jack Birkett & Brett Hardham | Jimmy Sarrin |
| 2011 | Andrew Teakel | Bennett Tucker | Morgan Persson-Clark |
| 2010 | Michael Jamieson | Brock Baker | Greg Smith |
| 2009 | Brent Walker & Rod Woodford | Michael Oldenhof | Lachlan Greig |
| 2008 | Brad Hutchinson | Brett Hardham ** | Ayden Kennedy |
| 2007 | Brad Hutchinson | Patrick Lee | Brent Walker |
| 2006 | Adam Bourke | Stephen Johnston | Brent Walker |
| 2005 | Scott Edgcumbe | Justin Morgan | Tim Hardham |
| 2004 | Paul Cameron | Andrew Butterfield | David Edgcumbe |
| 2003 | Lee Rowe | Michael Migliore | Steve Forcucci |
| 2002 | Kris Raukola ** | Justin Morgan | Glenn Tucker |
| 2001 | Kris Raukola | Jason Alexander | Chris Baker (club) Daniel Beddome (EFL) |
| 2000 | Jason Nitz | Andrew Derksen | Daniel Beddome ** |
| 1999 | Jason Heffernan | Andrew Derksen | Scott Edgcumbe |
| 1998 | Jason Heffernan | Darren Nelson | Sam Barnes ** |
| 1997 | Matty Schultz | Peter Markby | Michael Camilleri |
| 1996 | Kris Raukola | Shawn Barnett | Waine Ferguson |
| 1995 | Brendan Ferres | Peter Cutts | Daniel Ruffin |
| 1994 | Matty Schultz | Gary Jardine & Peter Rohrmann | NTF |
| 1993 | Matty Schultz & Darren Trotter | Gary Moon | NTF |
| 1992 | Garry Vear | John Hearn | NTF |
| 1991 | Garry Vear | Serge Buccilli | NTF |
| 1990 | Garry Vear | Peter Reid | Jason Denton |
| 1989 | Stuart Sonsie | Craig Waller | Jason Denton |
| 1988 | Chris Rogers | Craig Waller | |
| 1987 | Ron Griffiths | Manny DeBono | Paul Payne |
| 1986 | Chris Marslin | Peter Auel | Louie Dibianco |
| 1985 | Paul Ladiges & Chris Marslin | Dave Connors & Leno Gasparroni | James King |
| 1984 | Phil Atkins | Alby Zantuck | Brendan White |
| 1983 | Mick Graham | Brian Sweetman | D Holbrook |
| 1982 | Mick Toleman | Ian Buck | |
| 1981 | John Tyquin | Kerry Mason | |
| 1980 | Mick Toleman | Dean Pusenjack | |
| 1979 | Doug Graham | A Baltruschaitis | |
| 1978 | Phil Atkins | Les Brick | |
| 1977 | Phil Atkins | Wes Ball | |
| 1976 | Phil Atkins | Peter Marinello | |
| 1975 | Doug Graham | David Atkins | |
| 1974 | Phil Atkins | John Hogan | |
| 1973 | Peter Scott | Jack Lind | |
| 1972 | Rob Penny | Jack Lind | |
| 1971 | Finn Hansen | Keith Pritchett | Neil Dandlion ** (U17) |
| 1970 | Phil Brewis | Rex Downward | Colin Voight ** (U17) |
| 1969 | Robert Taylor | Phil Brewis | |
| 1968 | Laurie Goodman | Danny Hogan | Robert Penny |
| 1967 | Des Brown | Ray Chalker | |
| 1966 | Laurie Goodman | Finn Hansen | |
| 1965 | Fred Smith | Lance Mitchell | David Atkin |
| 1964 | Alan Collins | Graeme Christie | |
| 1963 | Doug Lockwood | ||
| 1962 | Alan Hills | ||
| 1961 | |||
| 1960 | NTF | Doug Lockwood | |
| 1959 | NTF | Doug Lockwood | |
| 1958 | Ray Ajani | NTF | N Patterson (U16) Graeme Finger (League) |
| 1957 | Ray Ajani | NTF | NTF |
| 1956 | Ray Ajani | NTF | NTF |
| 1955 | NTF | NTF | |
| 1954 | NTF | NTF | |
| 1953 | NTF | NTF | |
| 1952 | Bob Dobson | NTF | NTF |
Wantirna South Devils